After yet another year that has zoomed by, we’re back!
This time, equipped with a quintet of yuletide content that runs the gamut from the expected feel good viewing to mainstream nostalgia trips that remind this jaded millennial just how nostalgic the 1990s are. .
A Cinderella Christmas Ball
They did it.
They did it everyone!
Finally, a prince with PERSONALITY!
Took them long enough to discard the life-sized Ken dolls for a cheeky prince and his iconic new pickup line: “Do you want to pay full price?”
Our favorite new Christmas prince, Philip, (played by Oliver Rice) joins yuletide season staple Danica McKellar, this time reincarnated as adoptee/dance instructor Chelsea, who travels to Philip’s tea brand homeland on a quest to find her father.
I’ll leave you the film to watch and explain if she does succeed in this quest, but I can tell you what else she gets up to while in the tea brand land of Havenshire: questionable dancing, split second existential crises, and a range of unexplainable social faux pas in cozy, fire (place) side Christmas gatherings.
Overall, a perfectly adequate, perfectly cheeky new addition to what I can imagine is an already extensive Christmas filmography for the lovely Ms. McKellar.
Champagne Problems
Doe-eyed American lead Sydney (Minka Kelly) travels to the City of Lights to close a business deal on a French vineyard, and the first thing she runs into is a Frenchman so stereotypical it feels like he stepped out of a romance novel. Predictably, whirlwind romance ensues.
She’s in for a rude awakening the next morning when she finds out her starlight lover happens to be the son of the man whose vineyard she’s trying to acquire. Needless to say, things go from romantic to rocky in an instant.
I don’t know what exactly I was expecting from Champagne Problems, but I felt like it could’ve done more. Maybe it was because the leads just didn’t click for me–I was desperate for some palpable chemistry that I could root for, and I just didn’t feel it with Sydney and Henri. You would think the whirlwind romance bit could’ve helped, or the romantic scenery that is France, but it just wasn’t there.
I found myself rooting more for Henri’s dad Hugo and his budding relationship to Brigitte, one of Sydney’s competitors for acquiring Chateau Cassell.
Speaking of Brigitte, it was the ensemble cast ( primarily Sydney’s competitors for acquiring the Cassell vineyard) that saved this movie: from the fun-loving Roberto Salazar, to the stoic yet cheeky Otto Moller, to Hugo Cassell himself, whose character development from cold, grieving widower to laidback and loving made for one of the movie’s good bits. In all my years watching Christmas movies, this ensemble cast might just be my favorite so far.
At the end of the day, Champagne Problems feels like a perfect title for this film. I couldn’t think of a more first world problem than worrying about a Christmas movie.
Hot Frosty
Who would’ve thought that the Mean Girls Christmas Movie Multiverse would actually be a thing? Well, it is.
With a big, big sigh of relief–I’m happy to say I finally got through this movie.
Full disclosure: i was supposed to include it in last year’s list, but I just could not get through it. Ended up swapping it out for something else.
But this year, here I am–ready to recount the tale of how Gretchen Weiners was reincarnated into a diner owner/widow that ends up falling for who I can only describe as a snow bro. Wikipedia calls him Jack Snowman. I call him goofy. Like, really goofy.
…But, thankfully: not for long. Hot Frosty doesn’t have the extensive snowman lore I thought it would have, but one thing it does have is a heart. And the ability to weave together a very simplistic yet wholesome little plotline that chips away at Jack’s frosty interior, bringing to life a character that melts away at Kathy (Lacey’s character)’s grief and gives her the chance to love again.
Sprinkled together with cheeky comedy bits, Hot Frosty is just the right amount of feel good, perfect for any cozy Christmas day.
P.S. The world may know Lacey Chabert as Ms Gretchen Weiners, but she’s forever Eliza Thornberry to me!
Operation Mistletoe
When you talk about wasted potential, never forget to include Operation Mistletoe.
Out of all the films on this year’s list, I had the highest hopes for this one–interior designer lead, highschool crush, matchmaking shenanigans? All the ingredients for a fun and sweet romantic comedy? Check.
Quality execution that makes for a good Christmas movie? Failed. Failed… bigtime.
They even had a little love triangle going on with a third character! But did it lead to anything? Nooooo. Hell no. It didn’t at all! Third character Quinn turned out to be the human representation for big bad capitalism instead versus our beloved lead Grace’s nostalgic feelings about childhood memories in an old home that felt so cold you just knew no one lived there for so long (well, they got one thing right at least).
Make that two: lead couple Grace and Ryan capture the awkwardness of a reunion well, but the buck stops right there. Yet again, the chemistry is not chemistry-ing. I don’t know why Grace’s bff Olivia bothered making a mess by scattering herbs throughout town for a couple that just don’t seem to jive at all.
Speaking of that mess, why is the movie even called Operation Mistletoe? Olivia failed bigtime! I thought there was going to be some cheesy, cheeky explanation for the name (like maybe they almost kissed under mistletoe as teens but couldn’t confess because…) but no! It’s like they finished the script but left the title blank at the last minute and just decided to call it a day.
Sigh. This review makes me sad– all the ingredients for a feel good, Christmas themed staple and it turns out like this. Do it again! Don’t waste it.
Jingle All The Way
Closing out this year’s selection with a blast from the mainstream past: 1996’s Jingle All The Way is cut straight from the prime era of pre-governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, six years after Kindergarten Cop and five years after the sequel to Terminator.
Jingle All The Way has Arnie play Howard Langston, a workaholic dad with bad time management issues who doesn’t do his Christmas shopping until Christmas Eve, and, as a result, has to jet all around town just to find his son’s (extremely basic) dream Christmas gift, the toy everyone wants that season: a Turboman action figure.
Action film style shenanigans that range from Howard discovering an illegal counterfeit ring run by men dressed in Santas to running from a bomb explosion in a radio station, ensue.
A radio station?! How nostalgic.
In true Arnie Schwarzenegger fashion circa the 1990s, things cap off with a happy ending that’s also family friendly. What more can you ask for from a mainstream Christmas film?
I’m not the biggest Arnold fan, but even I can’t deny that I grew up on a lot of his films. Before streaming there were the VHS tapes we had of the Terminator films (which happened to be directors cut versions. We didn’t know what that meant back then). There were the regular screenings of Kindergarten Cop on HBO (when it was still a cable channel–I have no idea what it is these days, streaming aside). As such, this felt less like an item on my checklist but a nostalgic rewatch that took me back to simpler days–when you couldn’t just order your gifts online and actually had to go to a store to buy them.
The film’s main plotline speaks to consumerism itself, albeit in its more innocent days. One toy, all he needed was one toy to make his son happy. This was long before the days of blind boxes and labubus–long before consumerism consumed us the way it has in 2025.
Watching Jingle All The Way reminded me of the same time capsule nostalgia I felt when watching another 90s classic: You’ve Got Mail. Whilst Jingle All The Way brought us a story during the innocent days of consumerism, You’ve Got Mail was all about the internet in its infancy–long before it became the hotbed of nefarious deeds and the subject of endless Netflix cautionary tales. Another thing to love about You’ve Got Mail–the bookstores. A delightful throwback to the days when you actually read in them.
Now, they just don’t feel the same.
Going back to Jingle All The Way, the film feels like a time capsule to me-so it does make me wonder how a younger audience would receive the film. I mean, it checks all the boxes of a holiday movie, but feels rooted in its time and place.
But then, who knows? Maybe it could resonate in a few years.
I’m sure it’s worth a shot.