I don’t know if it’s because I’ve seen too much Christmas movies at this point, but I’m six years into this and… is it just me, or are Netflix Christmas movies getting so much worse?
This year’s film haul was quite a slog to get through–and it wasn’t because I spent every few minutes pausing to cringe or laugh at something ridiculous. Perhaps I should’ve gone with my original idea instead: switching streaming services for a Camp Fest series aptly named (Amazon) Prime Time.
But alas, here I am–stubborn to uphold a tradition that I started out of boredom in the middle of the busiest month of my year. For now, the big changes to Camp Fest can wait.
Catering Christmas
While vying for the chance to cater a prestigious local yuletide event, an up and coming caterer to be meets (and falls for!) the nephew of the event’s longtime host.
This was the film that gave me hope Camp Fest would start out well. As someone who works in the catering business, it was a pleasant surprise to see this career in a Christmas movie. Imagine the aesthetic holiday buffets! The pretty shots of holiday ham glowing under the soft white light as snow falls outside! The potential was there.
I’m afraid that’s all the movie has: potential. First of all, no one in catering has enough time to hang around with one client in the midst of December. That’s a universal busiest time of the year for people in food. Second of all, you should be hustling much harder if you’re an up and coming caterer trying to succeed. What are you doing focusing on this one dinner when you should be out there getting more clients?
Lastly, I’m not expecting The Bear level presentation of a life in the culinary world, but can you at least look like you actually spend time in the kitchen?
Forgive me. I think I may have gotten a little too caught up in the food related aspects of the film to even absorb the story. It’s not like I lost out–really.
There wasn’t much of a story to begin with.
A Merry Christmas Wish
Manhattan Marketer has to tie up loose ends at her uncle’s childhood farm after he dies. While back at his place, she encounters a former childhood friend who turns out to be running the farm that she’s meant to inherit. Connections, conversations, and the revival of tradition ensue.
There isn’t much to say about this movie. It’s not good, but it’s not absolutely awful either. The story was pretty straightforward, and if there’s one thing I can say I like about this and all the movies I’ve seen so far–it’s that they seem to do a good job of casting actors that look like real people. But, yet again… that’s where the good things end. They look like attractive, real people–but the leads don’t have chemistry. The male lead doesn’t manage to pass as being related to his onscreen sister. The female lead and her supposed ‘boyfriend’ at the start of the film look more like brother and sister. No wonder they broke up.
This film’s worst offense might be its main premise. Really? That’s it?! Your big Christmas wish, your big holiday tradition is a barn centric night market? There was barely a town’s worth of people in that barn. Looks to me like Manhattan Marketer isn’t that good at her job.
A Brush with Christmas
From the moment this film’s opening credits left in a wall shot that showed a fake diploma hanging on the protagonist’s restaurant wall, I knew I wasn’t going to like this movie. It didn’t help that our frustrated artist by night/ reluctant chef by day kept doing the stupidest things which burned whatever food she was cooking.
While Catering Christmas’ lead at least had to work to get her big gig, A Brush with Christmas’ lead had her mom’s dating skills to thank for keeping her busy throughout the holiday season. If you watch the movie, you’ll see what I mean.
The only thing this has going for it is the unique premise.
Fall Into Winter
So this is what happens when you get into some legal trouble helping your kid get into a good college–you end up making a movie about being a childish small town chocolatier.
Lori Loughlin does what she can with a script that makes her go from mature single mother to teenager with a grudge in minutes, triggered by a nickname as innocent as ‘Bean’. Her male lead looks like the adult version of a famous childhood character (I can’t remember which one!) and seems like a nice enough guy that Lori’s grudge doesn’t really make sense. Another thing that doesn’t make sense? The film’s hilarious final sequence, which does a terrible job of speed running romantic comedy tropes that have been done a thousand times better in the past.
Good rom coms that use the person-from-my-past trope often have two things: a substantial past event, and a character who still embodies the traits from the so-called ‘substantial past’ that they share with the protagonist, albeit to a lesser degree.
Brooks McLeod (what is that name!?) and Kerrie, Lori’s character, share the ‘substantial past’, but the traits are gone. He’s a totally different, grown-up person, and she just seems immature holding a grudge about something he didn’t even know about. I would’ve loved a harsher misunderstanding that would make sense for such a longtime grudge.
On the plus side, the film has some endearing side characters–Brooks’ dad and Kerry’s sole employee Alexandra are my favorites. Another positive–the way the film tied the leads’ teenage beliefs to their present circumstance. The theme of big business businessman vs small town shop owner was another thing I enjoyed.
B&B Merry
This was the last film on my list, and it inspired the theme for this year’s Camp Fest, which runs through most of this year’s selections. When stock images come to life, they become movies like B&B Merry, a film so… bland I can’t even remember the names of the lead characters. Every scene feels more like a still image that you end up finding when you type ‘Christmas’ in Google Images.
It’s honestly kind of sad, given that the film has a cool premise going with a travel influencer protagonist meeting her match in a rugged photographer slash handyman who just happens to co-own the B&B she visits. When I first chose this movie, I was at least expecting some cheeky comedy involving the B&B having bad plumbing or something. What I did get was empty rooms, two so-so B&B owners, and another example of an onscreen coupling devoid of chemistry.
The film’s major conflict presents such an outdated opportunity as a big deal that it just makes things look even worse.
Look, I know the holidays are a time when we can afford to waste time–but this film doesn’t even deserve that kind of time. Just skip it.